2(22)(e) - Income Tax Department & Assessee
PrintListen to this Article
2(22)(e) – A Long standing Dispute between Income Tax Department and Assessee:
Background of the Section:
It’s a regular practice between closely held group companies to transfer monies to meet their fund requirements (other than for regular business activities). In such cases, the lending company does not charge any interest on such funds transferred to other group companies.
Eg: H is the Holding Company having S1 and S2 Subsidiaries. S1 is a well settled company in respect of business having sufficient funds and sufficient accumulated profits whereas S2 Company is a newly formed company with new line of business.
Hence, S2 requires funds for meeting its set up and expansion. Whenever S2 company requires funds, S1 company used to fund its requirements without charging any interest because S1 is a sister concern.
It means the Holding Company is benefitting in indirect way by way of distribution of assets of S1 to its own subsidiary S2.
In order to bring these kind of transactions into tax bracket, the Income Tax Department makes best use of Section 2(22)(e).
What is Section 2(22)(e)?
As per Section 115O, any Domestic Company which declares, distributes or pays dividend (whichever is earliest) shall pay an additional income tax (tax on distributed profits) @ 15% on such dividend distributed.
The definition of dividend is prescribed in the Section 2(22) of the Income Tax Act, 1961.
As per Section 2(22), dividend includes –
a. Any distribution of accumulated profits whether capitalised or not if it entails release of any assets of the Company
b. Any distribution by a Company to its Preference Shareholders by way of a Bonus to the extent of accumulated profits whether capitalised or not.
c. Any distribution by a Company to its Shareholders at the time of liquidation to the extent it is attributable to accumulated profits whether capitalised or not.
d. Any distribution by a Company to its Shareholders on reduction of capital to the extent it is attributable to accumulated profits whether capitalised or not.
e. any payment by a company, not being a company in which the public are substantially interested, of any sum by way of advance or loan to a shareholder, being a person who is the beneficial owner of shares (not being shares entitled to a fixed rate of dividend whether with or without a right to participate in profits) holding not less than ten per cent of the voting power, or to any concern in which such shareholder is a member or a partner and in which he has a substantial interest (hereafter in this clause referred to as the said concern) or any payment by any such company on behalf, or for the individual benefit, of any such shareholder, to the extent to which the company in either case possesses accumulated profits.
Sub-section (e) plays an important role while taxing any payments by a Company to any persons who have substantial interest in the Company.
Prerequisites to tax u/s 2(22)(e):
1. There should exist accumulated profits in the books of the lending Company. If no profits are available, the distribution of assets cannot be termed as dividends.
2. Funding should not be against regular business transactions i.e. for purchase of goods / services. CIT vs Creative Dyeing & Printing (P) Ltd.
3. Funding should be in the form of a Loan or Advance only.
4. Any subsequent dividend distributed to the extent it is set off against any loan or advance shall not be treated as dividend.
5. Payment shall be made to the following persons shall only be taxed as deemed dividend.
a. Payment is made to the shareholder holding beneficial interest in shares of not less than 10% of the voting power.
Eg:Mr. X holds 10% of voting power in Company A. Company A lends an amount of Rs. 10,000 to Mr. X. In this case, Rs. 10,000 is taxable in the hands of Mr. X as deemed dividend.
b. Payment is made to the concern in which the shareholder in (a) above is a member or partner or holds beneficial interest in shares of not less than 20% in voting power.
Eg:Mr. X also holds 20% in Company B and Company A makes a payment of Rs. 10,000 to Company B. In this case also, Rs. 10,000 is taxable in the hands of Mr. X as deemed dividend (explained later why it is taxable in the hands of Mr. X).
c. Payment is made on behalf of and for the benefit of shareholder in (a) above.
Definition of Loan and Advance – What to include and what not to include?
The sub-clause (e) says that the funding should be in the form of a Loan or Advance and it should not be in on account of regular business transactions.
Hence, the following would be excluded from taxation u/s 2(22)(e).
1. Loans given by a company which is a NBFC to the specified persons. Since the regular business activity of a NBFC is to lend and take loans and advances, these kinds of funding are not taxable. DCIT vs JK Credit and Finance Ltd.
2. Inter Corporate Deposits (ICDs) given by a company to the specified persons shall not be covered since the funding shall be in the form of Loan or advance. DCIT vs Bombay Oil Industries Ltd.
3. Monies given by a Company for specific purpose to the specified persons shall not be taxable like Security Deposit in case of premises taken for lease. ACIT vs Harshad V Doshi.
4. Monies given to a registered shareholder who is not a beneficial shareholder and given to a beneficial shareholder but not registered shareholder. Eg: Mr. X is a having a shareholding of 10% in Company A but the beneficial owner of such shares is Mr. Y. In this case, amounts lent by Company A to either Mr. X or Mr. Y is taxable as deemed dividend. DCIT vs Madhusudan Investment & Trading Co Pvt Ltd and CIT vs Standipack Pvt Ltd.
Taxable in whose hands?
The whole intention of this sub-section is to tax the shareholder since the dividend is to be taxed only in the hands of a shareholder. This was reiterated in many cases and all the appellate authorities confirmed that even though the transactions are between common interest companies, the deemed dividend shall be assessed in the hand of the shareholders only. CIT vs Ankitech Pvt Ltd, Mukul International Ltd, Active Securities Pvt Ltd, Magic International Pvt Ltd, etc.,
Why it is so critical to closely held Companies in purview of Income Tax?
Since majority of the closely held companies frequently transfer funds for purposes other than mentioned earlier, due care should be taken while remitting funds.
Hence, the Companies shall make funding either in the form of ICDs and shall be made to entities or persons who does not have common shareholding.
Category : Income Tax | Comments : 0 | Hits : 648
Income Tax Alert - Here Are 5 High-Value Transactions That May Come Under Scrutiny. Large Cash Deposits: Any cash deposit exceeding Rs 10 lakh in a financial year across savings accounts draws the attention of the income tax department. Even if deposits are spread across multiple accounts, the cumulative amount beyond the threshold triggers scrutiny. Fixed Deposits: Surpassing the Rs 10-lakh limit in fixed deposits within a financial year prompts inquiries regarding the source of f...
Delhi Court Sentences Woman to 6 months Jail for not filing the return of income (ITR) discussed. Accordingly, the accused is held guilty of not filing the return of income for the assessment year 2014-15 under Section 276CC of The Act. Accordingly, the accused is convicted for an offence punishable under Section 276CC of the Act," the court said in the judgement. "The convict is awarded a sentence of simple imprisonment for six months with a fine of Rs 5,000 and in default to unde...
Corporates, Non-corporates or government department all are procuring major part of services or goods from the MSMEs. There are provision under the Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises Development (MSMED) Act, to ensure that businesses make payments to MSMEs within a specified time frame, and failure to which can impact the deduction claims for such payments. To facilitate timely payments to micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs) and address the challenges faced by these businesses in rec...
In the Income tax act, the words “Turnover”, “Gross receipts” and Sales are used at many places. In the common business parlance, the terms sales and turnover are used interchangeably. However, as per Income Tax law, guidelines are available on the question of what constitutes turnover. Understanding the concepts of these words is necessary for the purpose of the tax audit. An audit is mandatory for corporate assessees, irrespective of the amount of turnover. In ...
Very Important Income Tax Update regarding Micro and Small Enterprises Section 43B-any amount remains unpaid on year end to creditors, being micro/small entity, beyond 45 days or less, as agreed or 15 days if no agmt, shall be added to taxable Income resulting in huge additional tax liability. Keeping such creditors unpaid is risky. If payment for purchases made from *Micro and Small units* remains outstanding on 31st March, there may be huge tax liability. Therefore...
Comments