No VAT on brand franchisee fee without transfer of effective control over brand
PrintListen to this Article
No VAT on brand franchisee fee without transfer of effective control over brand
State of Karnataka, Bangalore Vs. United Breweries Ltd. [(2015) 63 taxmann.com 41 (Karnataka)]
United Breweries Limited (“the Respondent”) being owner of Kingfisher Brand entered into contracts with certain Contract Bottling Units (“CBUs”) for manufacturing of beer.
In terms of the contract:
- The Respondent transferred know-how for manufacturing beer to CBUs which was on non-assignable, non-transferable and non-exclusive basis;
- The CBUs manufactured beer as per the specifications given by the Respondent using his trade marks, names and logos and the entire production was made available to the Respondent;
- The right to market, sell, distribute and package the beer remained under the supervision and control of the Respondent;
- The CBUs neither had any right over the product, nor did they have any right to sell or exploit the beer so produced, nor fix any price of the product.
The Respondent received payments from CBUs as 'brand franchise fees' and paid Service tax on the same. However, the Assessing Officer levied Sales tax on such payments by treating these as royalty.
The Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka held that it is settled law that Sales tax can’t be attracted until effective control is transferred. Since CBUs did not get effective control over the brand name as such, it could not be considered as sale of intangible goods. It was further held that since the Respondent had already paid Service tax on the amount received as brand franchise fees, double taxation on same goods is not permissible.
Category : VAT | Comments : 0 | Hits : 463
Introduction Regular audits are essential to ensure compliance and transparency in taxation. The new VAT Audit Form — 704 has brought out many major changes that are important for companies operating under the Sales Tax Act. The Maharashtra Value Added Tax Rules introduced this complete form with the objective of reducing the audit procedure and improving the effectiveness of tax administration. In this article, we’ll go into detail about the new VAT Audit Form 704, includin...
Sri Lakshmi Textiles Vs. the Commissioner of Commercial Taxes and Others [2016 (1) TMI 329 - MADRAS HIGH COURT] Facts: Sri Lakshmi Textiles(“the Petitioner”) is a partnership firm engaged in the business of inner garments and textiles registered under Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Act, 2006 (“TN Vat Act”). The Petitioner was regularly filing the VAT return and paying the VAT liability after adjusting the corresponding input tax credit. For the Assessment Year 2013-2014, th...
Now days for Trading goods online via. Flipkart , Amazon , Snapdeal , Shopclues etc. every dealer is required by such e commerce sites to obtain DVAT registration certificate so as to enroll themselves as dealer on such e commerce sites. In that case, If a person is willing to start new business then he shall apply for voluntary registration otherwise Mandatory registration. Let me tell you the difference between Mandatory & Voluntary registration Mandatory ...
A lot of queries comes to mind when one thinks about taking registration under Gujarat VAT and CST Laws. Some of the queries and their answers are published as follows for the benefits of the readers: What is VAT / CST / TIN / Sales Tax ? Answer: VAT means Value Added Tax On Sales. CST means Central Sales Tax. TIN means Tax Identification Number. And Sales Tax is Tax on Sales. In a Summarized way, in any State Law, two types of registrations are available. Fir...
Supply to high seas vessel is liable to VAT if any territorial nexus exist in the State Raj Shipping Vs. State of Maharashtra [2015 (62) taxmann.com 309 (Bombay)] In the instant case, Raj Shipping (“the Petitioner”) was engaged in "Bunker Supplies" which mainly consisted of supply of High Speed Diesel Oil (“HSD”) to various incoming and outgoing vessels within or beyond the port limits of Mumbai port. The Petitioner was not paying Sales tax on supply of HS...
Comments