ITAT: No scope for unilateral changes in taxation treaties
PrintListen to this Article
In a breather to multi-national companies working out of India, theMumbai Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has held that retrospectively amending the definition of ‘royalty’ in the Income Tax Act, 1961 cannot automatically alter the provisions of Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements.
The tribunal’s ruling, which comes in the case of WNS North America versus the Income Tax Department, would provide significant relief especially to IT and ITeS companies covered under such tax pacts. Many such firms have been reeling under a retrospective provision included in Budget 2012-13 that retrospectively widened the definition of ‘royalty’ from June 1, 1976.
Consequently, payments towards use of computer software, information, databases, transponder, uplinking facilities, leased lines have all become royalty and taxed accordingly.
While the tax department has said the changes were made to resolve conflicting decisions by various courts, it has irked software firms that will now face a massive rise in their tax burden.
But referring to the India- US tax avoidance pact that covers WNS North America, the tribunal has now held, “A country who is party to a treaty cannot unilaterally alter its provisions. If there is no amendment to the provision of the treaty but there is some amendments adverse to the assessee in the Act, which provisions has been specifically defined in the treaty or there is no reference in the treaty... the amendment... shall have no unfavourable effect on the computation of total income of the assessee.”
It has also stressed that any amendment to treaty can be made bilaterally by means of deliberations between the two countries who signed it. Alternatively, the domestic law will come into play only on reference by the treaty.
“The ruling has re-iterated that retrospective amendments in the domestic tax law do not impact the provisions in the tax treaty, unless either the treaty has also been amended on the same lines as the domestic law, or the particular provision in the tax treaty refers back to the domestic law,” said Sandeep Chaufla, executive director, PwC, adding that it also fortifies the taxability of reimbursements towards expenses incurred on behalf of the payer.
Category : Income Tax | Comments : 0 | Hits : 261
If you earn income other than salary or have multiple income streams, the advance tax deadline falling today—Monday, December 15, 2025—should not be overlooked. Failure to pay advance tax on time, or paying less than the required amount, may attract interest charges that continue to accumulate. As the Income Tax Act operates on a “pay as you earn” basis, being aware of advance tax provisions and the financial impact of delays can help you avoid unnecessary costs and last-...
If you earn income other than salary or have multiple income streams, the advance tax deadline falling today—Monday, December 15, 2025—should not be overlooked. Failure to pay advance tax on time, or paying less than the required amount, may attract interest charges that continue to accumulate. As the Income Tax Act operates on a “pay as you earn” basis, being aware of advance tax provisions and the financial impact of delays can help you avoid unnecessary costs and last-...
As many as 5,44,205 appeals were pending resolution with the Income Tax (IT) Department at commissioner (appeals) level as of January 31 this year, and 63,246 at various Income Tax Appellate Tribunals (ITATs), High Courts, and the Supreme Court, FE has learnt. To be precise, the cases pending in ITATs were 20,266 High Courts, 37,436; and Supreme Court 5,544. The large pendency is even as the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) has laid emphasis on disposing of income tax appeals in its 10...
The Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) has facilitated taxpayers to file their Income Tax Returns (ITRs) for the Assessment Year 2024-25 (relevant to Financial Year 2023-24) from 1st April, 2024 onwards. The ITR functionalities i.e. ITR-1, ITR-2 and ITR-4, commonly used by taxpayers are available on the e-filing portal from 1st April, 2024 onwards for taxpayers to file their Returns. Companies will also be able to file their ITRs through ITR-6 from April 1 onwards. As ...
It has come to notice that misleading information related to new tax regime is being spread on some social media platforms. It is therefore clarified that the new regime under section 115BAC(1A) was introduced in the Finance Act 2023 which was as under as compared to the existing old regime (without exemptions): New Regime 115BAC (1A) introduced for FY 2023-24 Existing old Regime 0-3 lacs 0% 0-2.5 lacs 0% ...
Comments