New Companies Act compels firms to conduct background checks on potential board members
Listen to this Article
The days when nomination of an independent director solely depended on his or her personal relationship with the promoter of any company could soon become a thing of the past.
As the new Companies Act makes independent directors more accountable, many listed as well as unlisted firms are undertaking background checks through forensic experts on professionals they intend to induct as board members. Professionals, who get calls to join boards as independent directors, are becoming more selective too, as they will be liable for company decisions.
"Increasingly , Indian companies are placing more rigor around the selection of appropriately qualified independent directors on their boards to deal with the myriad of regulatory and compliance requirements and the increased role that is being asked of directors," said Amry Junaideen, senior director, enterprise risk services, at Deloitte, India. "All companies should have a welldefined process for selecting independent board members."
In November, one of the top-50 listed companies was looking for an independent director. After zeroing in on a person, it hired one of the big four consultancy firms to do a background check. "It was more of a formality than a serious intention to put the director under scrutiny ," said a senior partner in the consultancy . "The director had claimed that he is a graduate from a premier management in stitute in a particular batch. We found otherwise, and reported back to the company ," he added.The company didn't nominate him to its board.
"In most cases, the information that we look up is whether there is an ongoing court case, or police case against the person, or if he is on the board of any other company that has anything which goes against the interest of the shareholder. However, we have to be cautious that while digging up the background information, we do not infringe on the person's personal space," said Mukul Shrivastava, partner, fraud investigation and dispute services, at Ernst & Young.
And, it is definitely not a oneway street, say industry experts.Professionals are increasingly hiring financial experts to examine the companies from where they get offers to join the board because an independent director too would be liable for any financial or other fraud the company may involve in.
"It is much tougher to be an independent director on the board of companies under the new Companies Act regime. Liability for an independent director has increased significantly , particularly because of financial and regulatory issues that the company may face," said Akshay Chudasama, senior partner at law firm J Sagar Associates, who is also an independent director on the board of Bata India andApollo Tyres.
"Such directors are no longer entitled to have stock options which make the risk-reward ratio unfavorable for independent directors. Further, activist investors and fund houses have started to voice their concerns when a company appoints related (conflicted, not only in a legal sense) persons as an independent director," said Chudasama. "However, things are becoming more transparent which will be good for the business ecosystem in the long term."
Industry experts say that as a result of the new rules, industry would see a dearth of eligible independent directors over the next two years.
"Given that the number of professionals who qualify to be directors and the increased scrutiny that they would face, there is a potential for a shortage of independent directors in the com ing years. Therefore, it is imperative that companies and Indian business as a whole pay more attention to board training and succession planning," said Junaideen of Deloitte.
Under the Act, independent directors have little or no defence against any misdeeds by the company since they would still be treated equivalent to the other directors by holding them responsible for decisions made through board processes.
"It is the individuals who have become more cautious and selective in being appointed as independent directors due to the additional responsibilities that the Act imposes on independent directors," said Sanjay Asher, senior partner at law firm Crawford Bayley & Co, who is also an independent director at Ashok Leyland and Shree Renuka Sugars.
"Independent directors are more cautious, selective and vigilant and, while choosing to be on the board of any company, they look at things such as the auditors of the company, whether they are one of the big four, what are the internal control mechanisms, who are the internal auditors and the constitution of the board, among other things."(Economic Times)
Category : Corporate Law | Comments : 0 | Hits : 350
Ashneer Grover, former managing director of BharatPe, has moved the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Delhi, alleging opression and mismanagement at the company. The case came up for hearing on December 6, wherein his lawyer sought additional time to address the tribunal on maintainability. The case will be heard next on January 11. According to the plea, reviewed by Moneycontrol, Grover has filed the plea against BharatPe holding company Resilient Innovations and 11 of its directors i...
Over 96,000 companies have wound up their operations in the past five years, according to the Ministry of Corporate Affairs. Businesses opt for winding up for various reasons, including financial unviability. From April 1, 2018 to March 31, 2023, as many as 96,261 companies exited voluntarily, invoking a section in the Companies Act, according to a report in the Mint. According to the data from the ministry, under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), final resolution orders have be...
Three board members of Ed tech company Byju’s resigned on Thursday, June 22. According to reports, Peak XV Partners' GV Ravishankar, Prosus' Russell Dreisenstock and Chan Zuckerberg Initiative's Vivian Wu have stepped down from their responsibilities from the board. The company spokespersons have denied reports dismissing them as speculative. Meanwhile, The Ken has reported that Byju’s auditor’s Deloitte Haskins & Sells had also stepped down with immedi...
The Enforcement Directorate has accused Amway India Enterprises of running a multi-level marketing scam, while attaching its assets worth Rs 757 crore on Monday, including its factory in Tamil Nadu’s Dindigul district and bank balances of Rs 346 crore. The agency said its money trail against Amway revealed that the company had collected Rs 27,562 crore from its business operations from 2002-03 to 2021-22. Out of this, Amway paid a commission of Rs 7,588 crore to its distributors and m...
The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI) has issued a fresh set of rules to fast track voluntary liquidation by companies under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC). The amendments to the IBBI (voluntary liquidation process) regulations notified on Tuesday sharply cuts short the time allowed to complete various procedures, showed an official order. As per the new regulations, the timeline for preparation of list of stakeholders by liquidators has been shortened to 15 day...


Comments